•  
  •  
 

Abstract

The Cleburne Living Center, Inc. v. City of Cleburne court faced the issue with a well-reasoned and carefully structured opinion. The court explored the indicia of suspectness promulgated by the Supreme Court in various opinions, and held that the mentally retarded share sufficient indicia of a suspect class to be accorded quasi-suspect status; therefore, intermediate scrutiny is the proper level of scrutiny to employ when examining the constitutionality of a statute. The largest part of the court's opinion dealt with the analysis of whether the discriminatory classification bore a substantial relationship to an important governmental objective - the required test under intermediate scrutiny. The court found that the City of Cleburne could not meet this test.

Share

COinS